Pep would make united as good as man city wright #comments

A bold claim!

Here are some comments responding to the idea that Pep Guardiola would make Manchester United as good as Manchester City:

Pro-Pep:

• "I completely agree! Pep's tactical genius and ability to get the best out of his players would undoubtedly elevate United to a new level. He's proven it time and time again with Barcelona and City."
• "United need a manager who can bring a winning mentality and a clear vision to the club. Pep has all the qualities to do just that. He'd make United a force to be reckoned with in the Premier League and Europe."
• "Pep's attention to detail and ability to adapt his tactics to suit his players would be a huge asset for United. He'd get the best out of players like Rashford, Martial, and Greenwood."

Anti-Pep:

• "I don't think Pep would be interested in managing United, and even if he was, I'm not convinced he'd be able to turn the club around. United's squad is too old and too flawed to be transformed overnight."
• "Pep's style of football is all about possession and tiki-taka, which wouldn't suit United's more direct and physical approach. He'd struggle to get the best out of players like Pogba and Fernandes."
• "United need a manager who can build a team around their existing players, not try to impose his own style and philosophy. Pep would be too focused on his own ego and would clash with the players and the board."

Neutral:

• "While Pep is an incredible manager, I'm not sure he'd be the right fit for United. He's had success with City, but that's largely due to the resources and talent at his disposal. United's squad is a work in progress, and Pep might not have the patience to wait for it to gel."
• "Pep's success is largely dependent on the players he has at his disposal. If United's squad is as flawed as it is now, even Pep wouldn't be able to turn them into title contenders."
• "While Pep would undoubtedly bring a level of tactical sophistication to United, I'm not convinced he'd be able to overcome the club's deeper issues, such as their lack of depth and squad cohesion."