New birth it's impossible

I understand your skepticism! The concept of reincarnation or rebirth is a complex and debated topic in various spiritual and philosophical traditions. While some believe in the possibility of rebirth, others argue that it's impossible or unlikely. Let's explore some of the arguments for and against the idea of new birth:

Arguments for new birth:

  1. Spiritual or philosophical beliefs: Many Eastern spiritual traditions, such as Hinduism, Buddhism, and Jainism, believe in the concept of reincarnation or rebirth. According to these beliefs, the soul or consciousness continues to exist after death and is reborn into a new body.
  2. Near-death experiences: Some people who have had near-death experiences (NDEs) report feeling a sense of continuity with their past life or experiencing visions of their past lives. While NDEs are not conclusive evidence of reincarnation, they can be seen as anecdotal support for the idea.
  3. Unexplained phenomena: Some people claim to have memories or skills from past lives, which they attribute to reincarnation. While these claims are often anecdotal and difficult to verify, they can be seen as intriguing and potentially suggestive of reincarnation.

Arguments against new birth:

  1. Scientific skepticism: From a scientific perspective, the concept of reincarnation is difficult to prove or disprove. There is no empirical evidence to support the idea that consciousness or the soul can survive physical death and be reborn into a new body.
  2. Lack of empirical evidence: Despite claims of reincarnation, there is no concrete evidence to support the idea. No one has been able to provide a verifiable, empirical link between a past life and a current life.
  3. The problem of identity: If reincarnation were possible, it's unclear how our sense of identity and continuity would be maintained across multiple lives. Would we retain memories and experiences from past lives, or would we start anew each time?

Conclusion:

While the idea of new birth is intriguing and has been debated for centuries, it remains a topic of speculation and faith. Without empirical evidence to support the concept, it's difficult to say whether reincarnation is possible or not. Ultimately, the question of whether new birth is impossible or not is a matter of personal belief and philosophical perspective.